| 39-40 J.F. Connelly | 75-76 James Spahr | 2010-11 Margarito Ochoa |
| 40-41 John Creeger | 76-77 George Zinkhann III | 2011-12 Ross Smith, Jr. |
| 41-42 Robert K. Remsburg | 77-78 Vince Jenkins | 2012-13 Tim Stuart |
| 42-43 Rhea T. Kincaid | 78-79 Richard A. Killmeier | 2013-14 Don Keeney, Jr. |
| 44-45 Samuel T. Royer, Jr. | 79-80 William A. Willhide | 2014-15 Harold “JR” Wantz |
| 45-46 Dr. F.V. Swearingen | 80-81 William A. Willhide | 2015-16 William (Bill) Reckley |
| 46-47 M. O. Lawyer | 81-82 Donald Lewis | 2016-17 Robert Johnson |
| 47-48 Wilbur Freeze | 82-83 Michael Baltzell | 2017-18 Nadja Muchow |
| 48-49 Charles R. Ambrose | 83-84 Ross Smith, Jr. | 2018-19 Julie El-Taher |
| 49-50 Thomas B. Stone | 84-85 Glenn Rickard, Jr. | 2019-20 Joyce Anthony |
| 50-51 William A. Houck | 85-86 Frank C. Long, Jr. | 2020-21 Susan Favorite |
| 51-52 H. Lloyd Hoke | 86-87 Robert Meunier | 2021-22 Dianne McLean |
| 52-53 Ralph Stottlemyer | 87-88 H. Lloyd Hoke | 2022-23 Julie El-Taher |
| 53-54 Raymond Boarts | 88-89 William A. Willhide | 2023-24 Susan Favorite |
| 54-55 Daniel Weybright | 89-90 Michael Irons | 2024-25 Nancy Echard |
| 55-56 Elmer Chandlee | 90-91 Frank C. Long, Jr. | 2025-26 Bill Reckley |
| 56-57 Edgar B Palmer | 91-92 Robert Lookingbill | 2026-27 |
| 57-58 Lee Saylor | 92-93 Eugene Long | |
| 58-59 John R. Routh | 93-94 Ralph Fisher | |
| 59-60 Ernest Tresselt | 94-95 Margarito Ochoa | |
| 60-61 Donald Lewis | 95-96 Frank Dardanell | |
| 61-62 William Benjamin | 96-97 John Hart | |
| 62-63 Robert Schumann | 97-98 William Long | |
| 63-64 Victor R. Jagow | 98-99 Larry West | |
| 64-65 Victor A. Leisner | 99-2000 Eugene Long | |
| 65-66 George Campbell | 2000-01 Douglas Favorite | |
| 66-67 Eugene Anderson | 2001-02 Sharon Ochoa | |
| 67-68 W. Roy Hoover, Jr. | 2002-03 William Reckley | |
| 68-69 Martin Mathwig | 2003-04 Jenny West | |
| 69-70 Denton Twigg | 2004-05 Shirley Long | |
| 70-71 Robert Ogle | 2005-06 Sam Miller | |
| 71-72 Murray C. Miller | 2006-07 Susan Favorite | |
| 72-73 Earl Shankle | 2007-08 Paul Cannada | |
| 73-74 Howard Schildt | 2008-09 Robin Keeny | |
| 74-75 Clarence Hagelin | 2009-10 George Bolling | |
